Warm neutral steakhouse dining corner with a leather banquette, walnut table and black-framed warehouse window.

The West Loop's New Steak Rooms, From Fulton to Randolph

"I hope to kind of shatter people's expectations a bit by what we're presenting," chef John Manion told Block Club Chicago this month. He was talking about Palomino, the steakhouse he is building in the former Proxi at 565 W. Randolph St.

The expectations he means are Chicago's own: dark wood, heavy leather and a porterhouse the size of a hubcap. In the West Loop, that classic version and the rethinks of it now sit within a short walk of each other. Gibsons is coming west from Rush Street. A Randolph Street steakhouse is adding a weekend bakery. A Morgan Street gastropub cooks over coals. And Palomino is due in early 2027. A neighborhood that grew up around meatpacking now offers four different answers to what a meat-and-fire dinner should be.

Fulton Street gets the classic, rebuilt as a tavern

Gibsons Restaurant Group first announced Gibsons Tavern in 2023, and set Nov. 17 as its opening date. It sits on the ground floor of an 11-story office building at 925 W. Fulton St., according to Block Club Chicago.

What sets this location apart from the Rush Street original, which opened in 1989, is how directly it borrows from the West Loop's past. Liz Lombardo Stark, the group's director of marketing and public relations, told Block Club the concept reimagines the neighborhood taverns where meatpacking workers might have stopped for a beer and a hearty meal. The interior is meant to evoke the early 1900s, with a library-style room, warm leather booths and artwork about Chicago history. Mark Knauer, who designed the original Gibsons more than 37 years ago, came back to design this one, and Antunovich Associates served as architect.

The building holds two different evenings:

  • The tavern faces Fulton Street. It is open for lunch and dinner, with a large bar, televisions for games and comfort food like a $16 chicken pot pie, a $22 tavern burger and a $35 prime Angus French dip.
  • The main dining room serves dinner Tuesday through Saturday. Entrées run from a $35 rotisserie chicken to a $176 48-ounce porterhouse. A $225 seafood tower and a caviar service found only at this Gibsons round it out.

So a weeknight burger at the bar and an anniversary porterhouse share one address. A private event space with its own outdoor entrance, bar and fireplace is due in about eight months, per Block Club. That puts it in mid-2027, after this holiday season.

Randolph Street already has a steakhouse that breaks the mold

Susu, at 652 W. Randolph St., is the reminder that the rethink began before Palomino. Eater Chicago describes it as a steakhouse blending Middle Eastern, Mediterranean and Asian influences. On Oct. 17 it started a weekend bakery, with breakfast sandwiches and pastries available for pre-order and pickup at the back entrance.

The bakery's main item is a wagyu sujuk breakfast sandwich. It layers wagyu beef sujuk sausage, French scrambled eggs, American cheese, red shatta aioli and green chermoula on hand-rolled sourdough pita. The pastry case includes croissants, a chai Tea Tea Cheesecake, a shakshuka danish, tahini chocolate chip cookies and a tahini canelé, plus an occasional mystery item, per Eater. A steakhouse you can visit on a Saturday morning is a useful thing to know about when out-of-town guests stay for a holiday weekend.

Morgan Street cooks over coals, gastropub-style

Black Briar opened Sept. 26 at 201 N. Morgan St., in the 110-seat room that used to be Bar Takito. Chef Jimmy Papadopoulos and co-owner Tim Anderson met at Bellemore, and Eater Chicago sums up the restaurant as a gutsy gastropub filtered through an American lens.

It belongs in a steakhouse conversation because of its Josper grill. The pork short rib, which Papadopoulos says is a cut you can get only at Black Briar, is brined, smoked and cooked sous vide before it finishes on the coals under an apple cider glaze. Even the bar uses the fire. The Ashton Martin is a martini-style drink infused with grill coals that have been coated in fat from the meat roasting above.

The room leans tavern too: U-shaped booths, brass chandeliers, a 20-seat U-shaped bar beside the raw bar and hot line, and a host stand made from an antique Argentine butcher block. "We wanted this to feel lived in," Anderson told Eater. There is a short kids' menu, and the restaurant is open 4 to 10 p.m. daily.

Palomino, the one still under construction

Palomino takes the farthest step from the classic model, and it arrives last. Block Club reports construction should wrap up around mid-December, with an opening between mid-January and early March.

Manion's version is "distinctly American," drawing on Texas, Oklahoma, California and the Gulf Coast. Steaks slow-cook over wood before they finish on the grill. Beyond beef, the menu plans call for American-sourced duck, quail, pheasant and rabbit. One dish already set: quail stuffed with house-made duck sausage over white beans, with charred, marinated radicchio and poblano salsa verde. The raw bar trades East Coast accompaniments for Mexican, Texan and Gulf Coast flavors such as comeback sauce. The wine list is 100 percent American-made.

Carlos Cruz, formerly of John's Food and Wine, will lead the kitchen. Melody Arnold, a longtime Manion collaborator from El Che and Brasero, joins him, and Alex Cuper runs the bar. Proxi regulars will recognize the bones: the 17-foot windows and the open-fire hearth stay, joined by a custom smoker from Lockhart, Texas. "It's going to be lighter, brighter," Manion told Block Club. Chicago firm Siren Betty is designing the roughly 150-seat room.

The four rooms side by side

Room Address The fire The feel When
Gibsons Tavern 925 W. Fulton St. Prime steaks, seafood tower, caviar Early-1900s library, leather booths Opening date set for Nov. 17; dining room Tue–Sat
Susu 652 W. Randolph St. Steakhouse with Middle Eastern, Mediterranean and Asian influences Weekend bakery pickup at the back entrance Bakery since Oct. 17
Black Briar 201 N. Morgan St. Josper grill, coal-finished meats English-pub chandeliers, U-shaped bar 4–10 p.m. daily since Sept. 26
Palomino 565 W. Randolph St. Wood-smoked steaks, Lockhart smoker Light, bright, 17-foot windows Expected mid-January to early March 2027

When the table runs out of steak, the same few blocks opened other rooms this fall. Lettuce Entertain You's Pizzeria Gabbo opened Oct. 22 at 834 W. Fulton Market, Suite 200, serving both New York- and Chicago-style pies. The U.K. Persian restaurant Berenjak opened Oct. 2 at Soho House, 113–125 N. Green St., with black chickpea hummus, kababs and charcoal-grilled prawns, per Eater Chicago.

Getting to Randolph from the east this season

If you come in from the Loop side, the Lake Street bridge over the river matters for every dinner on this list. Its lower level has been closed to vehicles and pedestrians since Oct. 6, 2025. According to the Chicago Department of Transportation, pedestrians are sent via Canal Street to Wacker Drive on Randolph Street. Construction is expected to finish in January 2028.

The L is easier for now. The CTA restored normal Green and Pink Line service on Oct. 29 after replacing the bridge's west leaf. The east leaf goes in during spring 2027, and the CTA expects similar service impacts then. CDOT's project page expects that shutdown to last about 13 days, which could overlap Palomino's first weeks.

The closure has changed Lake Street itself. Open Books closed its store at 651 W. Lake St. on Nov. 8 after more than a decade at that address, and Block Club Chicago reports a curated selection of its books moved to Open Books Pilsen at 905 W. 19th St.

A short calendar through early spring

  1. Now: Black Briar serves nightly from 4 p.m., and Susu's bakery runs on weekends. Gibsons Tavern's opening date was set for Nov. 17.
  2. Dec. 12–13: The Randolph Street Holiday Market returns to 1340 W. Washington St. with indoor dealers, food and a bar, per the organizer's schedule.
  3. Mid-January to early March 2027: Palomino's expected opening window on Randolph.
  4. Spring 2027: The east-leaf shutdown on the Green and Pink Lines.

If one of these dinners has you picturing a home a few blocks from Fulton Market or Randolph, I would be glad to walk those blocks with you and talk through how each pocket of the West Loop lives day to day. Colby Price can arrange the tour around a reservation. Schedule your concierge consultation.

WORK WITH COLBY

I’m here to guide you every step of the way and help you find a home that not only fits your needs but also aligns with your vision for the future.

Follow Me on Instagram